Cynicism
January 15th, 2012The 2nd Sunday after the Epiphany
John 1:43-51
O Lord, you have taught us that without love whatever we do is worth nothing; Send your Holy Spirit and pour into our hearts your greatest gift, which is love, the true bond of peace and of all virtue, without which whoever lives is accounted dead before you. Grant this for the sake of your only Son Jesus Christ, who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever. Amen [BCP, 216]. “Can anything good come out of Nazareth?” There is a certain cynical, jaded tone to Nathaniel’s comment that reminds me of the cynicism of Humphrey Bogart’s Rick in the movie Casablanca. Rick’s cynicism is like a protective scab for a broken heart. Despite his bitter attitude, you know that Rick remains a romantic at heart and ultimately will do what is right. There is a cosmopolitan sophistication to his cynicism that at first seems attractive. He isn’t someone who will be easily fooled. He’s too smart for that. But you also sense the limits of his cynicism; how it keeps him from being fully present, fully alive. Instead of being an asset, it’s a liability. Today we are well aware of the limits of cynicism. In a post-modern culture that celebrates a cynical attitude towards everything, there is little personal commitment and all truth feels relative. There are local truths but few if any Capital T Truths. A detached ironic attitude is the default mode for today’s hipster, what was once a unique trait to Rick has become a commonplace. Such cynical detachment far from being attractive breeds boredom and complacency. Instead of working to better the world, time hangs heavily and one seeks distractions to make it pass more quickly.
I’m not sure how cynicism has become a default attitude in our society. Perhaps it’s a consequence of the popularization of the Theory of Relativity, or a consequence of the loss of idealism after the assignations of President Kennedy and Martin Luther King Jr., or the bitterness that followed Vietnam and Watergate. In terms of the history of philosophy it’s interesting how cynicism has changed from a basically positive stoic attitude towards life in the ancient world, an indifference to suffering similar to Buddhism, to today’s negative indifference to anything and everything. Modern cynicism is a parasitic belief that feeds off of the beliefs of others but offers nothing in their place. “Can anything good come out of Nazareth?” “Can anything good come out of Christianity?” quickly leads to “Is anything good?” It’s hard to combat cynicism; it’s like trying to stand on quicksand. You feel like yours words are meaningless and falling into a void. But instead of responding directly to cynical words you might respond as Philip and Jesus do in the Gospel this morning. When Nathaniel asks, “Can anything good come out of Nazareth?” Philip doesn’t argue back. He just says “Come and see.” He doesn’t try to convince Nathaniel that he Philip is right. He honors Nathaniel’s position and invites Nathaniel to make up his own mind. Come and see. In a similar fashion, instead of arguing for the truth of our faith in Christ, invite someone to come to Church with you or take them to the soup kitchen on Saturday. Come and see, it’s all the evangelism that we need to do. It’s not our job to make people Christian, that’s the role of the Holy Spirit. Our job is just to issue the invitation, Come and see. God will do the rest.
And that’s what we see happen with Jesus and Nathaniel. Instead of berating Nathaniel for his cynicism, Jesus commends him for being without guile. Instead of being upset that Nathaniel dissed his hometown, Jesus sees behind his cynicism to a desire for the Messiah to really come. Jesus appeals to Nathaniel’s hope instead of his disappointment. He then reveals to Nathaniel the depths to which God knows him when he says that he saw him under the fig tree. The fig tree was both a traditional place of study for a rabbi and also a symbol of the Law. Jesus knows that Nathaniel is a person of faith despite his cynical comment.
Might we make the same assumption today about people today? Instead of assuming their cynicism is permanent, appeal to the desire for Capital T Truth and extend an invitation to Come and see, to experience Jesus in worship, to experience Jesus in outreach. Christianity has always had its cultural despisers, people who belittle the faith or see it as simple and unsophisticated. Wherever the Church has existed, people have wondered if anything good can come out of Nazareth? The simplest and best response is to invite them to come and see. Jesus will do the rest. Amen.